/
Slab Reinforcement Verification

Slab Reinforcement Verification

Owned by mert.goktas (Unlicensed)
Last updated: Dec 11, 2022
12 min read

Safe & Aecbolt Slab Design Analysis Result Comparison

Project

 

Top Reinforcements , Column Strip Reinforcements

 

COLUMN STRİP REINFORCEMENT

 

COLUMN STRİP REINFORCEMENT

Analysis Source: Aecbolt

Analysis Source: Safe (Wall Takes Out of Plane Moment Unchecked)

Rebar

Spacing

Count Of Rebars

Prvd. Intensity

Layer

Linked Columns/Wall

Tonnage (lb)

Rebar

Spacing

Count Of Rebars

Prvd. Intensity

Layer

Linked Columns/Wall

Tonnage (lb)

#6

18

11

0.293

2nd Layer

SW 4-CZ 4

91.47

#6

18

11

0.293

2nd Layer

SW 4-CZ 4

91.47

#6

18

4

0.293

1st Layer

SW 4-CZ 4

99.54

#6

18

4

0.293

1st Layer

SW 4-CZ 4

99.54

#6

18

9

0.293

2nd Layer

SW 4-CZ 3

117.27

#6

18

9

0.293

2nd Layer

SW 4-CZ 3

117.27

#6

18

6

0.293

1st Layer

SW 4-CZ 3

149.31

#6

18

6

0.293

1st Layer

SW 4-CZ 3

149.31

#6

13

14

0.406

2nd Layer

SW 4-CZ 2

184.51

#6

14

13

0.377

2nd Layer

SW 4-CZ 2

171.33

#6

7

14

0.754

1st Layer

SW 4-CZ 2

348.40

#6

13

8

0.406

1st Layer

SW 4-CZ 2

199.08

#6

18

11

0.293

2nd Layer

SW 4-CZ 1

96.52

#6

18

11

0.293

2nd Layer

SW 4-CZ 1

96.52

#6

17

5

0.311

1st Layer

SW 4-CZ 1

124.43

#6

17

5

0.311

1st Layer

SW 4-CZ 1

124.43

#6

18

11

0.293

2nd Layer

SW 3-CZ 4

89.00

#6

18

11

0.293

2nd Layer

SW 3-CZ 4

89

#6

18

4

0.293

1st Layer

SW 3-CZ 4

99.63

#6

18

4

0.293

1st Layer

SW 3-CZ 4

99.63

#6

18

9

0.293

2nd Layer

SW 3-CZ 3

116.59

#6

18

9

0.293

2nd Layer

SW 3-CZ 3

116.59

#6

18

6

0.293

1st Layer

SW 3-CZ 3

149.46

#6

18

6

0.293

1st Layer

SW 3-CZ 3

149.46

#6

11

16

0.48

2nd Layer

SW 3-CZ 2

207.27

#6

16

12

0.33

2nd Layer

SW 3-CZ 2

155.45

#6

11

9

0.48

1st Layer

SW 3-CZ 2

224.19

#6

15

7

0.352

1st Layer

SW 3-CZ 2

174.37

#6

18

11

0.293

2nd Layer

SW 3-CZ 1

89.00

#6

18

11

0.293

2nd Layer

SW 3-CZ 1

89

#6

14

5

0.377

1st Layer

SW 3-CZ 1

124.54

#6

15

5

0.352

1st Layer

SW 3-CZ 1

124.54

#6

18

5

0.293

2nd Layer

SW 2-CZ 2

109.40

#6

18

5

0.293

2nd Layer

SW 2-CZ 2

109.4

#6

18

9

0.293

1st Layer

SW 2-CZ 2

83.76

#6

18

9

0.293

1st Layer

SW 2-CZ 2

83.76

#6

18

5

0.293

2nd Layer

SW 2-CZ 1

109.40

#6

18

5

0.293

2nd Layer

SW 2-CZ 1

109.4

#6

18

9

0.293

1st Layer

SW 2-CZ 1

91.99

#6

18

9

0.293

1st Layer

SW 2-CZ 1

91.99

#6

18

5

0.293

2nd Layer

SW 1-CZ 2

109.39

#6

18

5

0.293

2nd Layer

SW 1-CZ 2

109.39

#6

18

9

0.293

1st Layer

SW 1-CZ 2

91.24

#6

18

9

0.293

1st Layer

SW 1-CZ 2

91.24

#6

18

5

0.293

2nd Layer

SW 1-CZ 1

109.39

#6

18

5

0.293

2nd Layer

SW 1-CZ 1

109.39

#6

18

9

0.293

1st Layer

SW 1-CZ 1

91.35

#6

18

9

0.293

1st Layer

SW 1-CZ 1

91.35

#6

16

6

0.33

2nd Layer

C 35

47.09

#6

18

6

0.293

2nd Layer

C 35

47.09

#6

9

7

0.587

1st Layer

C 35

100.09

#6

12

6

0.44

1st Layer

C 35

85.79

#6

14

7

0.377

2nd Layer

C 34

99.02

#6

16

6

0.33

2nd Layer

C 34

84.88

#6

18

6

0.293

1st Layer

C 34

80.09

#6

18

6

0.293

1st Layer

C 34

80.09

#6

17

6

0.311

2nd Layer

C 33

47.89

#6

18

6

0.293

2nd Layer

C 33

47.89

#6

13

5

0.406

1st Layer

C 33

67.27

#6

13

5

0.406

1st Layer

C 33

67.27

#6

12

8

0.44

2nd Layer

C 32

110.93

#6

15

7

0.352

2nd Layer

C 32

97.07

#6

17

7

0.311

1st Layer

C 32

65.90

#6

18

6

0.293

1st Layer

C 32

56.49

#6

18

6

0.293

2nd Layer

C 14

124.77

#6

18

6

0.293

2nd Layer

C 14

124.77

#6

18

8

0.293

1st Layer

C 14

115.15

#6

18

8

0.293

1st Layer

C 14

115.15

#6

12

11

0.44

2nd Layer

C 13

232.76

#6

13

10

0.406

2nd Layer

C 13

211.6

#6

16

10

0.33

1st Layer

C 13

208.60

#6

12

13

0.44

1st Layer

C 13

271.18

#6

15

10

0.352

2nd Layer

C 12

236.55

#6

13

11

0.406

2nd Layer

C 12

260.21

#6

12

12

0.44

1st Layer

C 12

242.33

#6

13

11

0.406

1st Layer

C 12

222.13

#6

18

6

0.293

2nd Layer

C 11

121.15

#6

18

6

0.293

2nd Layer

C 11

121.15

#6

18

8

0.293

1st Layer

C 11

114.79

#6

18

8

0.293

1st Layer

C 11

114.79

#6

13

13

0.406

2nd Layer

C 10

187.87

#6

17

10

0.311

2nd Layer

C 10

144.51

#6

16

5

0.33

1st Layer

C 10

46.06

#6

13

6

0.406

1st Layer

C 10

55.27

#6

13

13

0.406

2nd Layer

C 9

207.59

#6

18

10

0.293

2nd Layer

C 9

159.69

#6

16

5

0.33

1st Layer

C 9

45.86

#6

15

5

0.352

1st Layer

C 9

45.86

#6

13

13

0.406

2nd Layer

C 8

204.21

#6

18

10

0.293

2nd Layer

C 8

157.08

#6

15

5

0.352

1st Layer

C 8

46.47

#6

17

5

0.311

1st Layer

C 8

46.47

#6

13

13

0.406

2nd Layer

C 6

110.72

#6

18

10

0.293

2nd Layer

C 6

85.17

#6

13

5

0.406

1st Layer

C 6

117.77

#6

10

7

0.528

1st Layer

C 6

164.88

#6

13

13

0.406

2nd Layer

C 4

112.06

#6

18

10

0.293

2nd Layer

C 4

86.2

#6

16

5

0.33

1st Layer

C 4

117.77

#6

15

5

0.352

1st Layer

C 4

117.77

#6

12

14

0.44

2nd Layer

C 2

116.71

#6

18

10

0.293

2nd Layer

C 2

83.37

#6

6

10

0.88

1st Layer

C 2

241.06

#6

11

6

0.48

1st Layer

C 2

144.63

 

 

 

COLUMN STRİP REINFORCEMENT

AECBOLT- SAFE RESULT DIFFERENCE

Rebar

Spacing

Count Of Rebars

Prvd. Intensity %

Tonnage (lb)

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

1

1

7.143

7.143

Same

6

6

46.154

42.859

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

5

4

31.250

25.001

Same

4

2

26.667

22.222

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

1

0

6.631

0.000

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

2

0

11.212

0.000

Same

3

1

25.043

14.287

Same

2

1

12.467

14.280

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

1

0

5.788

0.000

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

3

1

20.000

12.494

Same

1

1

5.788

14.279

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

1

1

7.727

9.091

Same

4

3

33.333

30.000

Same

2

1

15.341

10.002

Same

1

1

7.727

8.336

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

0

0

0.000

0.000

Same

4

3

23.399

23.080

Same

3

1

23.030

19.996

Same

5

3

27.833

23.074

Same

1

0

6.667

0.000

Same

5

3

27.833

23.079

Same

2

0

11.648

0.000

Same

5

3

27.833

23.076

Same

3

2

30.049

40.002

Same

5

3

27.833

23.077

Same

1

0

6.667

0.000

Same

6

4

33.409

28.567

Same

5

4

45.455

40.002

Column Strip Reinforcements in CAD view

Safe

 

 

 

Top Reinforcements , Middle Strip Reinforcements

 

Middle Strip Reinforcement

 

Middle Strip Reinforcement

Analysis Source: Aecbolt

Analysis Source: Safe Wall Takes Out of Plane Moment No

Rebar

Spacing

Req/Prvd Intensity

Prvd. Intensity

Layer

Linked StressLine

Tonnage (lb)

Rebar

Spacing

Req/Prvd Intensity

Prvd. Intensity

Layer

Linked StressLine

Tonnage (lb)

#6

18

0.18 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-SW 3-CZ 4-SW 4-CZ 4

37.07

#6

18

0.13 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-SW 3-CZ 4-SW 4-CZ 4

37.07

#6

18

0.2 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-SW 3-CZ 1-SW 4-CZ 1

18.53

#6

18

0.1 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-SW 3-CZ 1-SW 4-CZ 1

18.53

#6

18

0.05 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-SW 1-CZ 2-SW 3-CZ 2

97.86

#6

18

0.02 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-SW 1-CZ 2-SW 3-CZ 2

97.86

#6

18

0.06 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-SW 1-CZ 1-SW 4-CZ 1

114.17

#6

18

0.06 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-SW 1-CZ 1-SW 4-CZ 1

114.17

#6

18

0.06 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-SW 1-CZ 1-SW 4-CZ 2

97.86

#6

18

0.03 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-SW 1-CZ 1-SW 4-CZ 2

97.86

#6

18

0.15 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 35-SW 1-CZ 1

44.23

#6

18

0.07 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 35-SW 1-CZ 1

44.23

#6

18

0.12 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 35-SW 4-CZ 2

74.87

#6

18

0.06 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 35-SW 4-CZ 2

74.87

#6

18

0.09 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 34-SW 2-CZ 1

41.79

#6

18

0.07 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 34-SW 2-CZ 1

41.79

#6

18

0.1 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 33-SW 2-CZ 2

41.76

#6

18

0.06 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 33-SW 2-CZ 2

41.76

#6

18

0.14 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 32-SW 1-CZ 2

43.08

#6

18

0.06 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 32-SW 1-CZ 2

43.08

#6

18

0.11 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 32-SW 3-CZ 2

74.44

#6

18

0.08 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 32-SW 3-CZ 2

74.44

#6

18

0.13 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 14-SW 3-CZ 3

69.73

#6

18

0.08 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 14-SW 3-CZ 3

69.73

#6

18

0.12 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 14-SW 3-CZ 4

87.17

#6

18

0.08 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 14-SW 3-CZ 4

87.17

#6

18

0.1 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 14-SW 4-CZ 4

104.6

#6

18

0.08 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 14-SW 4-CZ 4

104.6

#6

18

0.2 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 13-C 14

74.45

#6

18

0.14 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 13-C 14

74.45

#6

18

0.15 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 13-C 33

112.81

#6

18

0.12 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 13-C 33

112.81

#6

18

0.12 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 13-SW 2-CZ 2

122.92

#6

18

0.17 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 13-SW 2-CZ 2

122.92

#6

18

0.05 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 12-C 13

161.13

#6

18

0.1 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 12-C 13

161.13

#6

18

0.04 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 12-C 14

123.26

#6

18

0.08 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 12-C 14

123.26

#6

18

0.11 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 12-C 34

130.28

#6

18

0.13 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 12-C 34

130.28

#6

18

0.09 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 12-SW 2-CZ 1

160.44

#6

18

0.08 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 12-SW 2-CZ 1

160.44

#6

18

0.22 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 11-C 12

74.45

#6

18

0.13 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 11-C 12

74.45

#6

18

0.05 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 11-C 14

77.85

#6

18

0.05 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 11-C 14

77.85

#6

18

0.13 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 11-SW 4-CZ 3

64.29

#6

18

0.08 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 11-SW 4-CZ 3

64.29

#6

18

0.11 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 11-SW 4-CZ 4

80.36

#6

18

0.08 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 11-SW 4-CZ 4

80.36

#6

18

0.2 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 10-C 32

43.1

#6

18

0.18 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 10-C 32

43.1

#6

18

0.27 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 10-SW 3-CZ 2

110.14

#6

18

0.17 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 10-SW 3-CZ 2

110.14

#6

18

0.12 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 10-SW 3-CZ 3

90.11

#6

18

0.08 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 10-SW 3-CZ 3

90.11

#6

18

0.18 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 9-C 10

33.58

#6

18

0.11 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 9-C 10

33.58

#6

18

0.15 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 9-C 14

110.11

#6

18

0.14 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 9-C 14

110.11

#6

18

0.21 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 9-SW 3-CZ 3

110.14

#6

18

0.15 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 9-SW 3-CZ 3

110.14

#6

18

0.19 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 8-C 9

33.7

#6

18

0.13 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 8-C 9

33.7

#6

17

0.3 / 0.31

0.31

1st Layer

SL-C 8-C 13

74.41

#6

18

0.14 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 8-C 13

74.41

#6

18

0.23 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 8-C 14

110.11

#6

18

0.14 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 8-C 14

110.11

#6

18

0.19 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 8-C 33

43.73

#6

18

0.13 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 8-C 33

43.73

#6

18

0.27 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 6-C 11

92.35

#6

18

0.17 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 6-C 11

92.35

#6

18

0.29 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 6-C 12

73.88

#6

18

0.17 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 6-C 12

73.88

#6

18

0.17 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 6-C 34

32.51

#6

18

0.13 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 6-C 34

32.51

#6

18

0.17 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 4-C 6

32.9

#6

18

0.16 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 4-C 6

32.9

#6

18

0.15 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 4-C 11

110.82

#6

18

0.14 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 4-C 11

110.82

#6

18

0.2 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 4-SW 4-CZ 3

110.05

#6

18

0.14 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 4-SW 4-CZ 3

110.05

#6

18

0.16 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 2-C 4

22.14

#6

18

0.16 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 2-C 4

22.14

#6

18

0.2 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 2-C 35

42.22

#6

18

0.18 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 2-C 35

42.22

#6

17

0.3 / 0.31

0.31

1st Layer

SL-C 2-SW 4-CZ 2

132.05

#6

18

0.2 / 0.29

0.29

1st Layer

SL-C 2-SW 4-CZ 2

110.05

#6

18

0.11 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 2-SW 4-CZ 3

89.43

#6

18

0.07 / 0.29

0.29

2nd Layer

SL-C 2-SW 4-CZ 3

89.43

COLUMN STRİP REINFORCEMENT

AECBOLT- SAFE WALL TAKE NO RESULT DIFFERENCE

Rebar

Spacing

Prvd Intensity %

Tonnage (lb)

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

1

6.45

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Same

1

6.45

16.66

Same

0

0.00

0.00

Middle Strip Reinforcements in CAD view

 

 

 

Punching Shear , D/C Ratio

 

Name

D/C Aecbolt

D/C Safe

Dif %

C 2

0.6

0.607

1.12

C 4

0.51

0.516

1.12

C 6

0.52

0.523

0.56

C 8

0.42

0.253

39.71

C 9

0.45

0.265

41.11

C 10

0.4

0.232

42.13

C 11

0.17

0.182

6.94

C 12

0.35

0.376

7.34

C 13

0.37

0.399

7.81

C 14

0.19

0.200

5.21

C 32

0.7

0.706

0.90

C 33

0.48

0.514

7.02

C 34

0.54

0.580

7.44

C 35

0.68

0.682

0.25

extension

 

Note: Explanation of the reason for the different % values

For C8 & C9 & C10 the reason why columns have different D/C % values is because Safe calculates “Punching Perimeter” incorrectly.

 

 

 

Related content

Base Reaction Verification
Base Reaction Verification
Building Design Suite
Read with this
Generation of Slab Reinforcement Rectangles [BDS]
Generation of Slab Reinforcement Rectangles [BDS]
Building Design Suite
More like this
Software User Interface Verifications
Software User Interface Verifications
Building Design Suite
Read with this
Rockwell Slab Example 1Plus
Rockwell Slab Example 1Plus
Building Design Suite
More like this
Designing Slab
Designing Slab
Building Design Suite
More like this
Top Slab Reinforcements
Top Slab Reinforcements
Building Design Suite
More like this