Content Comparison

Versions Compared

Version	Old Version 53	New Version Current
Changes made by	mert.goktas	mert.goktas
Saved on	Dec 11, 2022	Jan 06, 2023

Key

This line was added.
This line was removed.
Formatting was changed.

Safe & Aecbolt Base Reaction Comparison

Project

...

...

Aecbolt - Safe Column Base Reaction Comparison

	Self Weight			Super DL			LL wR			LL woR
Name	Aecbolt Local (kips)	Safe (kips)	Dif %	Aecbolt Local (kips)	Safe (kips)	Dif %	Aecbolt Local (kips)	Safe (kips)	Dif %	Aecbolt Local (kips)	Safe (kips)	Dif %
C2	38.840	38.517	0.83	33.449	33.207	0.72	9.376	9.316	0.64	-0.143	-0.304	-112.59
C4	39.189	39.567	0.96	32.707	32.754	0.14	9.347	9.436	0.95	-0.375	-0.412	-9.87
C6	38.750	37.171	4.07	33.227	31.41	5.47	9.548	8.94	6.37	-1.034	-0.66	-36.17
C8	41.574	40.321	3.01	34.658	33.45	3.49	10.383	9.934	4.32	-1.039	-0.881	-15.21
C9	40.176	40.393	0.54	33.820	33.208	1.81	9.715	9.736	0.22	-0.402	-0.413	-2.74
C10	40.773	40.588	0.45	34.485	33.851	1.84	9.762	9.763	0.01	-0.047	-0.28	-495.74
C11	45.359	44.960	0.88	4.829	4.858	0.60	8.618	8.675	0.66	3.59	3.164	11.87
C12	61.758	67.288	8.95	5.616	6.235	11.02	12.221	13.5	10.47	5.133	5.626	9.60
C13	63.978	69.673	8.90	6.158	7.129	15.77	12.64	13.97	10.52	5.626	6.103	8.48
C14	48.275	48.674	0.83	4.174	4.851	16.22	8.928	9.111	2.05	4.665	4.557	2.32
C32	25.792	27.208	5.49	24.848	25.801	3.84	6.095	6.523	7.02	0.013	-0.02	253.85
C33	21.762	22.656	4.11	16.274	16.032	1.49	4.358	4.523	3.79	-0.182	-0.082	-54.95
C34	26.706	28.585	7.04	24.190	24.114	0.31	5.885	6.407	8.87	-0.184	-0.043	-76.63
C35	22.779	23.590	3.56	17.537	17.733	1.12	4.808	5.017	4.35	0.008	-0.029	462.50
Total (kips)	555.71	569.19	2.43	305.97	304.63	0.44	121.68	124.85	2.60	15.63	16.33	4.46

Chart

thumbnail	true
borderColor
columns	Name, Aecbolt Local (kips), Safe (kips)
rangeAxisTickUnit	10
rangeAxisLowerBound	0
dataOrientation	vertical
title	Self Weight Comparison
type	xyLine
yLabel	Kips
colors	Blue, Green
bgColor
width	400
xLabel	Column
rangeAxisUpperBound	70
height	400

Name	Aecbolt Local (kips)	Safe (kips)
C2	38.840	38.517
C4	39.189	39.567
C6	38.750	37.171
C8	41.574	40.321
C9	40.176	40.393
C10	40.773	40.588
C11	45.359	44.960
C12	61.758	67.288
C13	63.978	69.673
C14	48.275	48.674
C32	25.792	27.208
C33	21.762	22.656
C34	26.706	28.585
C35	22.779	23.590

Chart

thumbnail	true
borderColor
columns	Name, Aecbolt Local (kips), Safe (kips)
rangeAxisTickUnit	5
rangeAxisLowerBound	0
dataOrientation	vertical
title	Super DL Comparison
type	xyLine
yLabel	Kips
colors	Blue, Green
bgColor
width	400
xLabel	Column
rangeAxisUpperBound	40
height	400

Name	Aecbolt Local (kips)	Safe (kips)
C2	33.449	33.207
C4	32.707	32.754
C6	33.227	31.41
C8	34.658	33.45
C9	33.820	33.208
C10	34.485	33.851
C11	4.829	4.858
C12	5.616	6.235
C13	6.158	7.129
C14	4.174	4.851
C32	24.848	25.801
C33	16.274	16.032
C34	24.190	24.114
C35	17.537	17.733

Chart

thumbnail	true
borderColor
columns	Name, Aecbolt Local (kips), Safe (kips)
rangeAxisTickUnit	2
rangeAxisLowerBound	0
dataOrientation	vertical
title	Self Weight Comparison
type	xyLine
yLabel	Kips
colors	Blue, Green
bgColor
width	400
xLabel	Column
rangeAxisUpperBound	14
height	400

Name	Aecbolt Local (kips)	Safe (kips)
C2	9.376	9.316
C4	9.347	9.436
C6	9.548	8.94
C8	10.383	9.934
C9	9.715	9.736
C10	9.762	9.763
C11	8.618	8.675
C12	12.221	13.5
C13	12.64	13.97
C14	8.928	9.111
C32	6.095	6.523
C33	4.358	4.523
C34	5.885	6.407
C35	4.808	5.017

Chart

thumbnail	true
borderColor
columns	Name, Aecbolt Local (kips), Safe (kips)
rangeAxisTickUnit	1
rangeAxisLowerBound	-2
dataOrientation	vertical
title	Self Weight Comparison
type	xyLine
yLabel	Kips
colors	Blue, Green
bgColor
width	400
xLabel	Column
rangeAxisUpperBound	6
height	400

Name	Aecbolt Local (kips)	Safe (kips)
C2	-0.143	-0.304
C4	-0.375	-0.412
C6	-1.034	-0.66
C8	-1.039	-0.881
C9	-0.402	-0.413
C10	-0.047	-0.28
C11	3.59	3.164
C12	5.133	5.626
C13	5.626	6.103
C14	4.665	4.557
C32	0.013	-0.02
C33	-0.182	-0.082
C34	-0.184	-0.043
C35	0.008	-0.029

...

Aecbolt - Safe ShearWall Base Reaction Comparison

	Self Weight			Super DL			LL wR			LL woR
Name	Aecbolt Local (kips)	Safe (kips)	Dif %	Aecbolt Local (kips)	Safe (kips)	Dif %	Aecbolt Local (kips)	Safe (kips)	Dif %	Aecbolt Local (kips)	Safe (kips)	Dif %
All Shearwall Nodes	678.37	637.57	6.01	55.52	55.57	0.09	78.64	75.63	3.82	67.96	66.69	1.86

Chart

borderColor
columns	Name, Aecbolt, Safe
rangeAxisTickUnit	50
rangeAxisLowerBound	0
dataOrientation	vertical
title	Aecbolt - Safe Shearwall Nodes Base Reaction Comparison
type	bar
yLabel	Kips
colors	Blue, Green, Red, Yellow
bgColor
width	400
xLabel	Name
rangeAxisUpperBound	600
height	400

Name	Aecbolt	Safe
Self Weight	678.37	637.57
Super DL	55.52	55.57
LL wR	78.64	75.63
LL woR	67.96	66.69

...

Aecbolt - Safe All Nodes Base Reaction Comparison

	Self Weight			Super DL			LL wR			LL woR
Name	Aecbolt Local (kips)	Safe (kips)	Dif %	Aecbolt Local (kips)	Safe (kips)	Dif %	Aecbolt Local (kips)	Safe (kips)	Dif %	Aecbolt Local (kips)	Safe (kips)	Dif %
Total (kips)	555.71	569.19	2.43	305.97	304.63	0.44	121.68	124.85	2.60	15.63	16.33	4.46
All Shearwall Nodes	678.37	637.57	6.01	55.52	55.57	0.09	78.64	75.63	3.82	67.96	66.69	1.86
Total	1234.08	1206.76	2.21	361.49	360.20	0.36	200.32	200.48	0.08	83.59	83.02	0.68

...

1	LL woR Manuel Calculation
2	Load Name	Load Type	LL woR	Area-Length	Fx (kips)
3	LG 2	Area	100	990.820
4	Opening	Area		-154.856
5	Remain	Area	100	835.964	83.596

...

Summary of Reaction Comparison

Name	Manuel Calculation	Aecbolt	Safe
Self Weight	1252.614	1234.18	1206.76
Super DL	364.720	361.61	360.20
LL wR	200.358	200.35	200.48
LL woR	83.596	83.59	83.03

...