Content Comparison

...

1

2

3

Manuel Calculation

4

Self Weight

Super DL

LL wR

LL woR

5

Code Block

Object Name	Area sq ft	height ft	Unit	kips
Slab	5624.473	1	150	
O1	68.469	1		
O2	86.387	1		
Slab Remain	5469.617	1	150	820.443
All Column	63.465	11	150	104.717
SW 1	23.911	11	150	39.453
SW2	23.913	11	150	39.456
SW3	72.177	11	150	119.092
SW4	73.763	11	150	121.709
LG 7	6.146		0.63	3.872
LG 8	6.146		0.63	3.872
Shearwall Total				327.454
Total				1252.614

Code Block

Load Name	Load Type	SDL	Area-Length	Fx (kips)
LG 1	Area	20	990.82	19.816
LG 3	Area	20	1901.81	38.036
LG 5	Area	20	2381.06	47.621
LG 13	Line	0.6	19.41	11.644
LG 14	Line	0.6	19.41	11.644
LG 15	Line	0.6	19.41	11.644
LG 16	Line	0.6	19.39	11.631
LG 17	Line	0.6	19.74	11.844
LG 18	Line	0.6	19.74	11.844
LG 19	Line	0.6	19.68	11.806
LG 20	Line	0.6	19.71	11.825
LG 21	Area	35	42.92	1.502
LG 22	Area	35	42.92	1.502
LG 23	Area	35	42.92	1.502
LG 24	Area	35	42.86	1.500
LG 25	Area	35	44.90	1.572
LG 26	Area	35	44.90	1.572
LG 27	Area	35	44.66	1.563
LG 28	Area	35	44.80	1.568
LG 29	Line	0.6	124.52	74.713
LG 30	Line	0.6	124.06	74.438
LG 9	Line	0.32	6.15	1.967
LG 11	Line	0.32	6.15	1.967
Topla				364.720

Code Block

Load Name	Load Type	LL wR	Area-Length	Fx (kips)
LG 4	Area	40	1901.811	76.072
LG 6	Area	40	2381.063	95.243
Clone LG 21	Area	60	42.922	2.575
Clone LG 22	Area	60	42.921	2.575
Clone LG 23	Area	60	42.923	2.575
Clone LG 24	Area	60	42.859	2.572
Clone LG 25	Area	60	44.902	2.694
Clone LG 26	Area	60	44.902	2.694
Clone LG 27	Area	60	44.662	2.680
Clone LG 28	Area	60	44.799	2.688
LG 10	Line	0.65	6.146	3.99
LG 12	Line	0.65	6.146	3.99
Total				200.358

Code Block
Load Name Load Type LL woR Area-Length Fx (kips) LG 2 Area 100 990.820 Opening Area 154.856 Remain Area 100 835.964 83.596

6

Safe - Aecbolt Analysis Result Comparsion

1	Project Name: Rockwell Slab Example Wall Take Plus
2	Include Automatic Rigid Zone Area Over Shearwall & Column button → Checked
3	Wall Takes Out-of-Plane Moment button unchecked

and


4	Slab & Column Rigid Materials arranged

...

Insertion Point

Bridge Parameters

5

Safe Analysis Result → Sum of Reactions

Image Added

6

All Structure (kips)

7

Code Block

IP1

Name

Abut1 0 -16.5 IP2 Abut1 0 -5.5 IP3 Abut1 0 5.5 IP4 Abut1 0 16.5 IP5 Pier2 0 -16.5 IP6 Pier2 0 -5.5 IP7 Pier2 0 5.5 IP8 Pier2 0 16.5 IP9 Pier3 0 -16.5 IP10 Pier3 0 -5.5 IP11 Pier3 0 5.5 IP12 Pier3 0 16.5 IP13 Abut4 0 -16.5 IP14 Abut4 0 -5.5 IP15 Abut4 0 5.5 IP16 Abut4 0 16.5

Code Block
1 2 3

Code Block

language	none

Slab rigid materials arranged to Rigid zone-conc 8000psi				
All Structure				
Name	Self Weight	Super DL	LL wR	LL woR
Aecbolt	1234.180	361.6102	200.3498	83.5929
Safe	1206.757	360.197	200.483	83.026
Diffe. (Kips)	27.423	1.4132	0.1332	0.5669
Dif %	2.22	0.39	0.07	0.68

TABLO OF VALUES

Code Block Top Elevation 144 inch Project Name: Rockwell Slab Example 1 Wall Take Plus SAFE ALL NODAL REACTION Tributary Column Column Tributary Area AECBOLT SHEARWALL NODAL REACTION SAFE SHEARWALL NODAL REACTION Slab thicknes 12 inch Include Automatic Rigid Zone Area Over Shearwall & Column button checked Self Weight Super DL LL wR LL woR Self Weight Super DL LL wR LL woR Area sq ft Self Weight Super DL LL wR LL woR Self Weight Super DL LL wR LL woR Column height 132 inch Wall Takes Out-of-Plane Moment button unchecked and Slab Rigid Materials arranged 38.517 33.207 9.316 -0.304 -39.7 -30.92 -9.46 0 C2 215.15 -3.6958 -3.8908 -1.3725 -0.0484 1 0.786 0.024 0.108 -0.002679 39.567 32.754 9.436 -0.412 -40.58 -30.58 -9.46 0 C4 215.53 9.2098 3.2941 1.8741 -0.0395 2 2.186 0.67 0.405 0.004273 Slab rigid materials arranged to Conc-8000psi 37.171 31.41 8.94 -0.66 -39.03 -30.23 -9.04 0 C6 205.21 7.1524 2.0479 1.3443 -0.0322 3 0.987 0.346 0.181 0.007423 All Structure Safe Nodal Reaction 40.321 33.45 9.934 -0.881 -42.12 -30.91 -9.91 0 C8 225.81 5.909 1.4309 1.0543 -0.0247 4 1.754 0.001021 0.219 0.057 Name Self Weight Super DL LL wR LL woR Self Weight Super DL LL wR LL woR 40.393 33.208 9.736 -0.413 -41.87 -31.62 -9.87 0 C9 224.11 5.3357 1.0551 0.8945 -0.0207 5 2.659 0.444 0.461 0.267 Aecbolt 1206.76 360.20 200.48 83.02 40.588 33.851 9.763 -0.28 -40.87 -31 -9.58 0 C10 217.48 4.7812 0.7291 0.747 -0.0173 6 5.542 0.374 0.721 0.798 Safe 44.96 4.858 8.675 3.164 -49.05 -5.55 -10.02 -2.72 C11 277.63 4.7199 0.546 0.6918 -0.0159 7 4.783 0.021 0.379 1.006 Diffe. (Kips) 0 0 0 0 67.288 6.235 13.5 5.626 -56.75 -6.52 -11.59 -3.64 C12 326.1 4.724 0.3699 0.6462 -0.0151 8 3.303 0.233 0.356 0.622 Dif % #SAYI/0! #SAYI/0! #SAYI/0! #SAYI/0! 69.673 7.129 13.97 6.103 -57.38 -6.61 -11.33 -4.71 C13 330.27 4.9947 0.2722 0.6517 -0.015 9 3.955 0.124 0.534 0.357 48.674 4.851 9.111 4.557 -51.4 -5.87 -9.5 -5.58 C14 293.3 5.0333 0.2124 0.6419 -0.0143 10 5.167 0.161 0.565 0.679 Slab rigid materials arranged to Rigid zone-conc 8000psi SAFE-SAFE DIF 27.208 25.801 6.523 -0.02 -29.58 -25.85 -7.19 0 C32 158.7 5.5827 0.2629 0.7241 -0.0142 11 4.384 0.528 0.352 0.993 All Structure Safe 1243.638 363.353 200.652 83.014 22.656 16.032 4.523 -0.082 -23.79 -16.28 -4.67 0 C33 114.6 6.822 0.4836 0.9418 -0.0142 12 2.988 0.02 0.239 0.465 Name Self Weight Super DL LL wR LL woR Safe 1206.757 360.197 200.483 83.026 28.585 24.114 6.407 -0.043 -30.16 -24.98 -6.85 0 C34 151.68 6.2411 0.7056 0.9458 -0.0088 13 3.592 1.059 0.664 0.004573 Aecbolt 1234.180 361.6102 200.3498 83.5929 Dif (kips) 36.881 3.156 0.169 -0.012 23.59 17.733 5.017 -0.029 -24.72 -17.76 -5.18 0 C35 126.28 5.455 0.8375 0.8952 -0.0041 14 3.732 1.019 0.677 0.002296 Safe 1206.757 360.197 200.483 83.026 0.786 0.024 0.108 -0.002679 567 294.68 123.65 16.65 Total 3081.85 7.0162 1.3603 1.2388 -0.0009 15 3.675 0.922 0.649 0.0007413 Diffe. (Kips) 27.423 1.4132 0.1332 0.5669 2.186 0.67 0.405 0.004273 9.7283 2.3633 1.854 0.0058 16 3.153 0.717 0.539 -0.0003201 Dif % 2.22 0.39 0.07 0.68 Rigid zone Area Height Unit kips 0.987 0.346 0.181 0.007423 Kolon Rigid Area 9.2329 2.6834 1.9 0.0073 17 3.306 0.672 0.545 -0.001066 "Shearwall Area" 23.911 1 150 3.587 1.754 0.001021 0.219 0.057 Name in in sq ft -4.7422 -2.5644 -1.3966 0.0118 18 3.414 0.605 0.539 -0.001753 SDL manuel Calculation 23.913 1 150 3.587 2.659 0.444 0.461 0.267 C 2 36 18 4.50 -1.7991 -1.8682 -0.9127 0.3546 19 3.215 0.479 0.483 -0.002171 Load Name Load Type SDL Area-Length Fx (kips) 73.763 1 150 11.064 5.542 0.374 0.721 0.798 C 4 36 20 5.00 8.6828 2.7405 1.7426 -0.03 20 3.034 0.369 0.432 -0.002466 LG 1 Area 20 990.82 19.816 72.177 1 150 10.827 4.783 0.021 0.379 1.006 C 6 36 20 5.00 7.102 1.8645 1.3106 0.0651 21 2.879 0.276 0.389 -0.002696 LG 3 Area 20 1901.81 38.036 Total 29.065 3.303 0.233 0.356 0.622 C 8 36 20 5.00 6.0082 1.3266 1.0434 0.1017 22 2.678 0.197 0.344 -0.002825 LG 5 Area 20 2381.06 47.621 3.955 0.124 0.534 0.357 C 9 36 20 5.00 5.5532 1.0085 0.9003 0.136 23 2.514 0.141 0.31 -0.002944 LG 13 Line 0.6 19.41 11.644 Aecbolt- Safe Shearwall Nodal Reaction Comparison 5.167 0.161 0.565 0.679 C 10 36 20 5.00 5.091 0.7318 0.7656 0.1632 24 2.458 0.107 0.294 -0.003177 LG 14 Line 0.6 19.41 11.644 Name Self Weight Super DL LL wR LL woR 4.384 0.528 0.352 0.993 C 11 17 38 4.49 5.1134 0.5764 0.7182 0.1968 25 2.429 0.089 0.286 -0.003459 LG 15 Line 0.6 19.41 11.644 Aecbolt 678.372 55.516 78.636 67.962 2.988 0.02 0.239 0.465 C 12 18 38 4.75 5.2048 0.4356 0.6811 0.2319 26 2.427 0.087 0.285 -0.003805 LG 16 Line 0.6 19.39 11.631 Safe 637.570 55.565 75.628 66.695 3.592 1.059 0.664 0.004573 C 13 38 18 4.75 5.5502 0.3592 0.6905 0.2694 27 2.454 0.099 0.291 -0.004222 LG 17 Line 0.6 19.74 11.844 Dif (kips) 40.802 -0.049 3.007 1.267 3.732 1.019 0.677 0.002296 C 14 17 38 4.49 5.6014 0.3184 0.6792 0.2804 28 1.953 0.091 0.236 -0.00364 LG 18 Line 0.6 19.74 11.844 Dif % 6.01 -0.09 3.82 1.86 3.675 0.922 0.649 0.0007413 C 32 36 14 3.50 6.1595 0.3782 0.755 0.2999 29 2.058 0.127 0.257 -0.004114 LG 19 Line 0.6 19.68 11.806 3.153 0.717 0.539 -0.0003201 C 33 36 16 4.00 7.3841 0.6287 0.9602 0.3187 30 2.745 0.207 0.353 -0.005919 LG 20 Line 0.6 19.71 11.825 Shearwall Rigid Zone- Self Weight Head Loss 3.306 0.672 0.545 -0.001066 C 34 35.94 18 4.49 6.5728 0.8525 0.9431 0.2201 31 2.874 0.274 0.387 -0.0067 LG 21 Area 35 42.92 1.502 Rigid Area height Unit kips 3.414 0.605 0.539 -0.001753 C 35 36 14 3.50 5.6069 0.9727 0.8788 0.1358 32 3.024 0.351 0.426 -0.007559 LG 22 Area 35 42.92 1.502 All SW 193.764 1 150 29.0646 3.215 0.479 0.483 -0.002171 Total Area 63.46 7.0492 1.5502 1.202 0.1066 33 3.188 0.434 0.468 -0.008473 LG 23 Area 35 42.92 1.502 3.034 0.369 0.432 -0.002466 9.5308 2.7128 1.7869 0.0357 34 3.356 0.515 0.511 -0.0094 LG 24 Area 35 42.86 1.500 Tributary Area 2.879 0.276 0.389 -0.002696 Area height Unit kips 8.8722 3.3508 1.8629 -0.0957 35 3.513 0.582 0.55 -0.01 LG 25 Area 35 44.90 1.572 SW 2540.821 1 150 357.895 2.678 0.197 0.344 -0.002825 63.46 1 150 9.520 -4.6824 -4.6507 -1.671 0.4001 36 3.361 0.57 0.535 -0.01 LG 26 Area 35 44.90 1.572 Openings 154.856 685.349 2.514 0.141 0.31 -0.002944 1.1659 0.6073 0.7988 -1.9187 37 3.154 0.514 0.503 -0.009887 LG 27 Area 35 44.66 1.563 Column 3081.85 2.458 0.107 0.294 -0.003177 SAFE SHEARWALL NODAL REACTION 8.2714 0.6027 0.7353 2.4488 38 3.017 0.414 0.47 -0.009752 LG 28 Area 35 44.80 1.568 Total 5467.815 2.429 0.089 0.286 -0.003459 Self Weight Super DL LL wR LL woR 9.7889 0.9696 1.1138 2.2337 39 2.137 0.189 0.316 -0.00712 LG 29 Line 0.6 124.52 74.713 2.427 0.087 0.285 -0.003805 637.57 55.57 75.63 66.69 9.026 0.9934 1.126 1.6796 40 2.943 0.23 0.409 0.055 LG 30 Line 0.6 124.06 74.438 Shearwall Rigid Zone- SDL Head Loss 2.454 0.099 0.291 -0.004222 9.4189 1.215 1.3396 1.3296 41 3.151 0.413 0.463 0.034 LG 9 Line 0.32 6.15 1.967 Load-SW Name SDL SW Area kips 1.953 0.091 0.236 -0.00364 SAFE COLUMN + SHEARWALL 10.1529 1.5554 1.6548 1.0299 42 3.186 0.477 0.473 0.029 LG 11 Line 0.32 6.15 1.967 LG 1 - (SW3+SW4) 20 145.940 2.919 2.058 0.127 0.257 -0.004114 1206.76 360.198 200.479 83.0209292 12.4027 2.2472 2.2779 0.8666 43 2.803 0.428 0.411 0.029 Topla 364.720 LG 3- SW 1 20 23.911 0.478 2.745 0.207 0.353 -0.005919 14.5227 3.1873 3.0935 0.332 44 3.012 0.439 0.43 0.041 LG 5 - SW 2 20 23.913 0.478 2.874 0.274 0.387 -0.0067 AECBOLT SHEARWALL NODAL REACTION -24.0605 -9.3545 -8.0394 2.6687 45 3.193 0.427 0.44 0.057 Self Weight Manuel Calculation Total 3.875 3.024 0.351 0.426 -0.007559 Self Weight Super DL LL wR LL woR 13.7989 2.9609 3.1303 0.1386 46 3.091 0.362 0.408 0.072 Area sq ft height ft Unit kips All Column 20 63.46 1.269 3.188 0.434 0.468 -0.008473 678.3721 55.5158 78.6355 67.9615 11.9147 2.2594 2.4836 0.3578 47 2.998 0.298 0.378 0.087 Slab Area 5624.473 1 150 Column include Facade 0.6 28.22916667 16.9375 3.356 0.515 0.511 -0.0094 8.294 1.3577 1.576 0.3648 48 2.92 0.242 0.352 0.101 O1 68.469 1 Total 22.082 3.513 0.582 0.55 -0.01 AECBOLT COLUMN + SHEARWALL 5.0583 0.6961 0.8601 0.259 49 2.781 0.192 0.323 0.11 O2 86.387 1 3.361 0.57 0.535 -0.01 1234.0831 361.488 200.3195 86.2565 7.3501 1.0249 1.2739 0.3359 50 2.666 0.157 0.301 0.116 Slab Remain 5469.617 1 150 820.443 SDL LG3 - Opening 20 154.856 3.097116222 3.154 0.514 0.503 -0.009887 8.2176 0.5595 0.8727 0.1545 51 2.65 0.141 0.295 0.121 All Column 63.465 11 150 104.717 LLwoR LG2- Opening 100 154.856 15.48558111 3.017 0.414 0.47 -0.009752 8.0348 0.4774 0.8802 0.591 52 2.653 0.139 0.295 0.125 SW 1 23.911 11 150 39.453 2.137 0.189 0.316 -0.00712 6.4232 0.4956 0.8551 0.9147 53 2.675 0.151 0.302 0.125 SW2 23.913 11 150 39.456 2.943 0.23 0.409 0.055 6.6234 0.4742 0.8332 0.9198 54 2.717 0.177 0.315 0.122 SW3 72.177 11 150 119.092 3.151 0.413 0.463 0.034 7.7608 0.5324 0.93 1.0549 55 2.168 0.166 0.259 0.092 SW4 73.763 11 150 121.709 3.186 0.477 0.473 0.029 6.8233 0.5111 0.8322 0.9705 56 2.274 0.204 0.282 0.089 LG 7 6.146 0.63 3.872 2.803 0.428 0.411 0.029 0.143 0.1444 -0.0014 6.2164 0.5587 0.8255 1.0377 57 3.025 0.329 0.392 0.106 LG 8 6.146 0.63 3.872 3.012 0.439 0.43 0.041 0.375 0.3661 0.0089 6.2874 0.4815 0.7488 0.8521 58 3.146 0.417 0.431 0.093 Total 1252.614 3.193 0.427 0.44 0.057 -1.034 1.0256 -2.0596 2.2293 -0.1697 0.0027 -0.4583 59 3.285 0.523 0.476 0.078 Shearwall Total 327.454 3.091 0.362 0.408 0.072 -1.039 1.0366 -2.0756 5.6107 0.4981 0.5986 1.0462 60 3.439 0.645 0.527 0.061 2.998 0.298 0.378 0.087 0.402 0.4 0.002 7.4957 0.3329 0.7787 0.4977 61 3.603 0.781 0.581 0.044 Column height 144 inch 2.92 0.242 0.352 0.101 0.047 0.0479 -0.0009 6.5745 0.4074 0.8651 0.643 62 3.769 0.928 0.636 0.028 Shearwall height 132 inch 2.781 0.192 0.323 0.11 3.59 -3.5847 7.1747 7.4966 0.4346 1.0258 0.7003 63 3.628 0.995 0.636 0.013 Column height Self Weight Super DL LL wR LL woR 2.666 0.157 0.301 0.116 5.133 -5.1357 10.2687 9.8879 0.4719 1.4228 0.7441 64 3.457 1.038 0.624 0.004425 Name Aecbolt Local (kips) Safe (kips) Dif % Aecbolt Local (kips) Safe (kips) Dif % Aecbolt Local (kips) Safe (kips) Dif % Aecbolt Local (kips) Safe (kips) Dif % 2.65 0.141 0.295 0.121 5.626 -5.6226 11.2486 8.718 0.3411 1.3844 0.4294 65 3.411 1.106 0.628 0.00361 C2 38.840 38.517 0.83 33.449 33.207 0.72 9.376 9.316 0.64 0.143 -0.304 312.5874126 2.653 0.139 0.295 0.125 4.665 -4.6564 9.3214 5.7343 0.1527 1.0463 0.0576 66 2.54 0.87 0.47 0.008735 C4 39.189 39.567 0.96 32.707 32.754 0.14 9.347 9.436 0.95 0.375 -0.412 209.8666667 2.675 0.151 0.302 0.125 0.013 -0.0129 0.0259 -8.0264 -0.9727 -3.9449 3.3278 67 4.967 0.396 0.724 0.52 C6 38.750 37.171 4.07 33.227 31.41 5.47 9.548 8.94 6.37 -1.034 -0.66 -36.17021277 2.717 0.177 0.315 0.122 0.182 0.1825 -0.0005 8.8671 0.2083 1.4418 0.3919 68 5.118 0.461 0.787 0.448 C8 41.574 40.321 3.01 34.658 33.45 3.49 10.383 9.934 4.32 -1.039 -0.881 -15.20692974 2.168 0.166 0.259 0.092 0.184 0.1864 -0.0024 8.4633 0.2183 1.0707 1.0176 69 5.853 0.567 0.901 0.539 C9 40.176 40.393 0.54 33.820 33.208 1.81 9.715 9.736 0.22 0.402 -0.413 202.7363184 2.274 0.204 0.282 0.089 0.008 -0.0086 0.0166 7.3662 0.2448 0.7429 1.3066 70 6.388 0.655 0.964 0.679 C10 40.773 40.588 0.45 34.485 33.851 1.84 9.762 9.763 0.01 0.047 -0.28 695.7446809 3.025 0.329 0.392 0.106 7.4755 0.3306 0.62 1.7305 71 6.401 0.688 0.932 0.811 C11 45.359 44.960 0.88 4.829 4.858 0.60 8.618 8.675 0.66 3.59 3.164 11.86629526 3.146 0.417 0.431 0.093 7.7473 0.4431 0.5401 2.2073 72 6.387 0.72 0.894 0.95 C12 61.758 67.288 8.95 5.616 6.235 11.02 12.221 13.5 10.47 5.133 5.626 9.604519774 3.285 0.523 0.476 0.078 9.066 0.6457 0.5655 3.0363 73 6.377 0.758 0.863 1.076 C13 63.978 69.673 8.90 6.158 7.129 15.77 12.64 13.97 10.52 5.626 6.103 8.478492712 3.439 0.645 0.527 0.061 5.6531 0.4944 0.2176 2.2143 74 6.419 0.815 0.859 1.164 C14 48.275 48.674 0.83 4.174 4.851 16.22 8.928 9.111 2.05 4.665 4.557 2.31511254 3.603 0.781 0.581 0.044 -2.3525 -0.6922 0.4387 -3.336 75 6.642 0.924 0.924 1.176 C32 25.792 27.208 5.49 24.848 25.801 3.84 6.095 6.523 7.02 0.013 -0.02 253.8461538 3.769 0.928 0.636 0.028 -1.1881 -0.0188 0.3515 -2.9164 76 5.739 0.886 0.885 0.837 C33 21.762 22.656 4.11 16.274 16.032 1.49 4.358 4.523 3.79 0.182 -0.082 145.0549451 3.628 0.995 0.636 0.013 5.2493 0.0701 0.1 1.6605 77 4.029 0.021 0.397 0.586 C34 26.706 28.585 7.04 24.190 24.114 0.31 5.885 6.407 8.87 0.184 -0.043 123.3695652 3.457 1.038 0.624 0.004425 12.1882 0.9125 1.1005 2.8661 78 4.424 0.055 0.503 0.444 C35 22.779 23.590 3.56 17.537 17.733 1.12 4.808 5.017 4.35 0.008 -0.029 462.5 3.411 1.106 0.628 0.00361 9.6269 0.838 1.0498 1.764 79 4.912 0.11 0.594 0.412 Total (kips) 555.711 569.191 2.43 305.972 304.633 0.44 121.684 124.851 2.60 18.295 16.326 10.76250342 2.54 0.87 0.47 0.008735 12.1254 1.3014 1.6244 1.7355 80 4.853 0.161 0.603 0.396 Total All load 4.967 0.396 0.724 0.52 16.8838 2.3071 2.983 1.2051 81 4.786 0.208 0.598 0.42 5.118 0.461 0.787 0.448 14.8545 2.5639 3.2137 0.2407 82 4.705 0.249 0.584 0.461 LL wR manuel Calculation 5.853 0.567 0.901 0.539 -28.2192 -8.3299 -8.9751 1.9319 83 4.613 0.282 0.564 0.506 Load Name Load Type LL wR Area-Length Fx (kips) 6.388 0.655 0.964 0.679 12.569 2.0756 2.7879 0.0159 84 4.514 0.307 0.541 0.546 LG 4 Area 40 1901.811 76.072 6.401 0.688 0.932 0.811 11.474 1.7045 2.3155 0.1661 85 4.41 0.322 0.517 0.578 LG 6 Area 40 2381.063 95.243 6.387 0.72 0.894 0.95 7.7765 0.9449 1.3565 0.2229 86 4.203 0.322 0.482 0.586 Clone LG 21 Area 60 42.922 2.575 6.377 0.758 0.863 1.076 4.701 0.4484 0.6986 0.1866 87 4.004 0.313 0.448 0.584 Clone LG 22 Area 60 42.921 2.575 6.419 0.815 0.859 1.164 6.9365 0.6864 1.0815 0.2285 88 3.917 0.307 0.427 0.589 Clone LG 23 Area 60 42.923 2.575 6.642 0.924 0.924 1.176 8.6744 0.5011 0.981 0.4735 89 3.84 0.297 0.409 0.588 Clone LG 24 Area 60 42.859 2.572 5.739 0.886 0.885 0.837 7.6374 0.2941 0.6719 0.5535 90 3.688 0.278 0.386 0.57 Clone LG 25 Area 60 44.902 2.694 4.029 0.021 0.397 0.586 5.4549 0.1912 0.4042 0.5031 91 3.557 0.259 0.368 0.549 Clone LG 26 Area 60 44.902 2.694 4.424 0.055 0.503 0.444 5.9499 0.2442 0.4163 0.6563 92 3.541 0.248 0.365 0.541 Clone LG 27 Area 60 44.662 2.680 4.912 0.11 0.594 0.412 7.4604 0.3741 0.4748 1.0711 93 3.552 0.24 0.37 0.531 Clone LG 28 Area 60 44.799 2.688 4.853 0.161 0.603 0.396 6.9925 0.4449 0.4284 1.2863 94 3.594 0.237 0.383 0.519 LG 10 Line 0.65 6.146 3.99 4.786 0.208 0.598 0.42 5.4404 0.3287 0.3713 0.7397 95 3.67 0.238 0.406 0.503 LG 12 Line 0.65 6.146 3.99 4.705 0.249 0.584 0.461 5.4254 0.3026 0.4315 0.3755 96 3.785 0.246 0.439 0.483 Total 200.358 4.613 0.282 0.564 0.506 3.6682 0.1652 0.3761 0.2473 97 3.939 0.261 0.482 0.457 4.514 0.307 0.541 0.546 4.3819 0.2649 0.2589 0.5 98 4.07 0.278 0.527 0.421 LL woR manuel Calculation 4.41 0.322 0.517 0.578 8.4915 0.5121 0.7123 1.1145 99 3.608 0.255 0.491 0.331 Load Name Load Type LL woR Area-Length Fx (kips) 4.203 0.322 0.482 0.586 6.6734 0.3851 0.655 0.7643 100 3.796 0.278 0.542 0.301 LG 2 Area 100 990.820 4.004 0.313 0.448 0.584 7.5057 0.4049 0.828 0.7327 101 3.958 0.299 0.585 0.279 Opening Area 154.856 3.917 0.307 0.427 0.589 10.2528 0.523 1.3856 0.7464 102 4.154 0.323 0.636 0.254 Remain Area 100 835.964 83.596 3.84 0.297 0.409 0.588 9.2151 0.4283 1.5211 0.3759 103 4.221 0.334 0.659 0.241 3.688 0.278 0.386 0.57 4.8361 0.1547 0.8553 0.0459 104 3.542 0.282 0.559 0.197 3.557 0.259 0.368 0.549 -9.7667 -0.1678 -4.5184 3.7603 105 4.948 0.389 0.773 0.315 3.541 0.248 0.365 0.541 8.732 0.2336 1.6356 0.0433 106 5.641 0.419 0.832 0.517 3.552 0.24 0.37 0.531 11.9985 0.3768 1.6184 1.3261 107 5.46 0.407 0.454 1.384 3.594 0.237 0.383 0.519 9.0588 0.3363 0.805 1.7474 108 5.136 0.366 0.356 1.448 3.67 0.238 0.406 0.503 7.9489 0.3566 0.4816 2.0578 109 5.049 0.32 0.345 1.378 3.785 0.246 0.439 0.483 11.0259 0.6302 0.4276 3.6693 110 4.986 0.268 0.363 1.244 3.939 0.261 0.482 0.457 5.4019 0.4096 -0.0759 2.268 111 4.932 0.213 0.392 1.083 4.07 0.278 0.527 0.421 -2.6646 -0.9723 0.1703 -3.5118 112 4.881 0.158 0.424 0.922 3.608 0.255 0.491 0.331 678.3721 55.5158 78.6355 67.9615 113 4.473 0.098 0.414 0.739 3.796 0.278 0.542 0.301 114 3.965 0.05 0.377 0.61 3.958 0.299 0.585 0.279 115 4.011 0.022 0.361 0.683 4.154 0.323 0.636 0.254 116 3.894 0.175 0.505 0.376 4.221 0.334 0.659 0.241 117 4.619 0.26 0.646 0.38 3.542 0.282 0.559 0.197 118 5.642 0.338 0.789 0.483 4.948 0.389 0.773 0.315 119 5.098 0.314 0.686 0.51 5.641 0.419 0.832 0.517 120 5.6 0.34 0.707 0.669 5.46 0.407 0.454 1.384 121 6.063 0.35 0.707 0.852 5.136 0.366 0.356 1.448 122 6.006 0.317 0.645 0.96 5.049 0.32 0.345 1.378 123 6.001 0.277 0.617 1.008 4.986 0.268 0.363 1.244 124 6.38 0.24 0.715 0.919 4.932 0.213 0.392 1.083 125 4.341 0.446 0.442 0.694 4.881 0.158 0.424 0.922 126 4.696 0.415 0.54 0.532 4.473 0.098 0.414 0.739 127 5.149 0.416 0.606 0.495 3.965 0.05 0.377 0.61 128 5.027 0.387 0.578 0.472 4.011 0.022 0.361 0.683 129 4.905 0.371 0.533 0.495 3.894 0.175 0.505 0.376 130 4.777 0.36 0.481 0.539 4.619 0.26 0.646 0.38 131 4.643 0.352 0.426 0.587 5.642 0.338 0.789 0.483 132 4.507 0.343 0.374 0.63 5.098 0.314 0.686 0.51 133 4.37 0.332 0.325 0.663 5.6 0.34 0.707 0.669 134 4.133 0.311 0.276 0.665 6.063 0.35 0.707 0.852 135 3.907 0.287 0.234 0.654 6.006 0.317 0.645 0.96 136 3.79 0.269 0.206 0.646 6.001 0.277 0.617 1.008 137 3.681 0.248 0.184 0.629 6.38 0.24 0.715 0.919 138 3.498 0.221 0.163 0.59 4.341 0.446 0.442 0.694 139 3.338 0.195 0.15 0.547 4.696 0.415 0.54 0.532 140 3.288 0.176 0.149 0.514 5.149 0.416 0.606 0.495 141 3.264 0.159 0.155 0.479 5.027 0.387 0.578 0.472 142 3.274 0.147 0.171 0.443 4.905 0.371 0.533 0.495 143 3.321 0.139 0.197 0.404 4.777 0.36 0.481 0.539 144 3.412 0.138 0.236 0.365 4.643 0.352 0.426 0.587 145 3.549 0.145 0.286 0.325 4.507 0.343 0.374 0.63 146 3.677 0.156 0.344 0.281 4.37 0.332 0.325 0.663 147 3.274 0.145 0.344 0.209 4.133 0.311 0.276 0.665 148 3.47 0.168 0.408 0.18 3.907 0.287 0.234 0.654 149 3.638 0.181 0.459 0.161 3.79 0.269 0.206 0.646 150 3.851 0.206 0.524 0.143 3.681 0.248 0.184 0.629 151 3.936 0.212 0.558 0.137 3.498 0.221 0.163 0.59 152 3.323 0.182 0.485 0.119 3.338 0.195 0.15 0.547 153 4.742 0.253 0.689 0.218 3.288 0.176 0.149 0.514 154 5.386 0.24 0.721 0.409 3.264 0.159 0.155 0.479 155 5.016 0.111 0.255 1.19 3.274 0.147 0.171 0.443 156 4.839 0.178 0.196 1.32 3.321 0.139 0.197 0.404 157 4.87 0.223 0.228 1.283 3.412 0.138 0.236 0.365 158 4.918 0.258 0.29 1.172 3.549 0.145 0.286 0.325 159 4.549 0.266 0.327 0.957 3.677 0.156 0.344 0.281 160 4.171 0.27 0.351 0.768 3.274 0.145 0.344 0.209 161 4.707 0.345 0.442 0.779 3.47 0.168 0.408 0.18 162 4.709 0.406 0.459 0.774 3.638 0.181 0.459 0.161 163 3.645 0.38 0.334 0.692 3.851 0.206 0.524 0.143 164 3.936 0.212 0.558 0.137 165 3.323 0.182 0.485 0.119 637.57 55.565021 75.628 66.6949292 4.742 0.253 0.689 0.218 5.386 0.24 0.721 0.409 5.016 0.111 0.255 1.19 4.839 0.178 0.196 1.32 4.87 0.223 0.228 1.283 4.918 0.258 0.29 1.172 4.549 0.266 0.327 0.957 4.171 0.27 0.351 0.768 4.707 0.345 0.442 0.779 4.709 0.406 0.459 0.774 3.645 0.38 0.334 0.692 1206.761 360.198021 200.479 83.0209292

Self Weight	Super DL	LL wR	LL woR
Aecbolt	1234.180	361.6102	200.3498	83.5929
Safe	1206.757	360.197	200.483	83.026
Diffe. (Kips)	27.423	1.4132	0.1332	0.5669
Dif %	2.22	0.39	0.07	0.68

Tip
Safe & Aecbolt analysis results were compared and it was understood that the values were very close to each other.

Version	Old Version 12	New Version 13
Changes made by	mert.goktas (Unlicensed)	mert.goktas (Unlicensed)
Saved on	Dec 07, 2022	Dec 07, 2022

Versions Compared

Key

Safe - Aecbolt Analysis Result Comparsion