Content Comparison

Versions Compared

Version	Old Version 2	New Version 3
Changes made by	Gokhan Alkan	Gokhan Alkan
Saved on	Apr 13, 2019	May 20, 2019

Key

This line was added.
This line was removed.
Formatting was changed.

...

Model

# Elm

Output Parameter

OpenBrIM

SAP2000

Independent

Percent Difference

(SAP2000 vs Independent)

Percent Difference

(OpenBrIM vs Independent)

A

1

Uz (midpt) in

AUz: −1.04167

-1.04167

-1.04167

0%

AUz%: 0%;

My (midpt) k-in

AMy: 22.500

22.500

22.500

0%

AMy%: 0%;

With Tension Stiffening - Using P-Delta Force Method

Model	# Elm	Output Parameter	OpenBrIM	SAP2000	Independent	Percent Difference (SAP2000 vs Independent)	Percent Difference (OpenBrIM vs Independent)
B	1	Uz (midpt) in	BUz: -0.58588	-0.54555	-0.54330	0.41%	BUz%: 7.84%;
B	1	My (midpt) k-in	BMy: 12.229	11.453	11.498	-0.39%	BMy%: 6.36%;
C	2	Uz (midpt) in	CUz: -0.56359	-0.54343	-0.54330	0.02%	CUz%: 3.73%;
C	2	My (midpt) k-in	CMy: 12.001	11.495	11.498	-0.03%	CMy%: 4.37%;
D	16	Uz (midpt) in	DUz: -0.56510	-0.54330	-0.54330	0%	DUz%: 4.01%;
D	16	My (midpt) k-in	DMy: 12.009	11.498	11.498	0%	DMy%: 4.44%;